The Australian report on Media Watch Ineptitude. A case study of Dunning Kruger effect...
The Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias wherein unskilled individuals suffer from illusory superiority, mistakenly assessing their ability to be much higher than is accurate. This bias is attributed to a metacognitive
inability of the unskilled to recognize their ineptitude. Conversely,
highly skilled individuals tend to underestimate their relative
competence, erroneously assuming that tasks which are easy for them are
also easy for others.
Legal move threatened over Media Watch report ACOUSTIC expert Steven Cooper is considering launching legal action against the ABC’s Media Watch program for its portrayal of him and his research on the effect of the Pacific Hydro wind turbines on local residents.
On the February 16 edition of Media Watch
host Paul Barry dished out a stinging criticism of Mr Cooper’s
seven-month study conducted at Cape Bridgewater in southwest Victoria —
and the reporting of it by The Australian’s environment editor Graham Lloyd and Network Seven’s Today Tonight.
However, in damning the report, the Media Watch
team hand- picked a group of pro-turbine “experts” — with no real
expertise in the field — ignored submissions from genuine acoustic
experts, misrepresented Mr Cooper, selectively and incorrectly quoted
the National Health and Medical Research Council, ignored balancing
quotes in the newspaper reports and made a number of factual mistakes.
Following his utter disbelief at Media Watch’s misrepresentation, as well as pending legal action, Mr Cooper has also sent a letter to the ABC demanding a retraction.
In response to the Media Watch report about The Australian’s coverage of wind farms
THE Media Watch report of
February 16 (“Turbine torture: do wind farms make you sick?”) is
littered with mistakes, omissions and misrepresentations from the
The program represents blatant advocacy for commercial interests
over the widespread concerns of a genuine minority group who deserve
thorough investigation of their complaints.
The Australian provided balanced, factual reporting of a national issue of public interest where Media Watch indulged in what amounts to little more than ad hominem, ideological propaganda.
The Media Watch program
misrepresented the National Health and Medical Research Council
position that the quality of existing research into the possible health
impacts of wind turbines is poor and that it will fund more high quality